Beloved Pink Sheep Dies

Pinky, the beloved pet of YoshiKarter, age 1 month, was recently found dead in the wild, next to some water. We are unsure if it was an accident or if foul play was involved. "She was like a... important sheep to me. I will miss her." says the unfortunate owner of the sheep.
Yoshi notes that roy405 took a visit to the shipwreck where Pinky was residing, and murdered him (Yoshi) twice. However, Pinky was also on a lead tied to a fence post in water, possibly raising the question of a drowning.
In the end, Pinky is dead, either by gun/sword or by water. Feel free to ask any questions you have here. RIP Pinky.